Donne's Holy Sonnet XII
Why are wee by all creatures waited on?
Why doe the prodigall elements supply
Life and food to mee, being more pure then I,
Simple, and further from corruption?
Why brook'st thou, ignorant horse,subjection?
Why dost thou bull, and bore so seelily
Dissemble weaknesse, and by'one mans stroke die,
Whose whole kinde, you might swallow'and feed upon?
Weaker I am, woe'is mee, and worse then you,
You have not sinn'd, nor need be timorous,
But wonder at a greater wonder, for to us
Created nature doth these things subdue,
But their Creator, whom sin, nor nature tyed,
For us, his Creatures, and his foes, hath dyed.
Annotated Bibliography
Beaston, Lawrence. "Talking to a Silent God: Donne's Holy Sonnets and the Via Negativa." Renascence: Essays on Values in Literature 51.2 (1999): 95-109. MLA International Bibliography. EBSCO. Web. 3 Mar. 2010.
In this article, Lawrence Beaston analyzes the purpose of Donne's poetry and its relationship it establishes with its audience. From the sophisticated language and subject of writing, it can be seen that the author is a credible journalist who writes for a more scholarly audience interested in analyzing English literature. The article is certainly a credible source, since it is a peer reviewed journal entry stored in the MLA International Bibliography Database. Though this article does not address my sonnet directly, it does provide useful background information and an analysis on Donne's writing style and use of rhetoric, which I can use to compare with the sonnet that I have chosen. Being less specific to a sonnet, this source will provide a good foundation and lead-in to any argument I choose to take.
Bellette, Antony F. "'Little Worlds Made Cunningly': Significant Form in Donne's Holy Sonnets and 'Goodfriday, 1613'." Studies in Philology 72.(1975): 322-347. MLA International Bibliography. EBSCO. Web. 3 Mar. 2010.
This is a journal article written by Antony Bellette assessing all of Donne's Holy Sonnets as a whole. The author is a journalist writing to cater researchers studying Donne's Holy Sonnets. The author cites evidence from all the sonnets throughout the peer reviewed essay to make claims about Donne's writing style and finds patterns among the sonnets, adding to the article's credibility. This author states that the sonnet that I have chosen lacks a "sense of crisis and disorder which is central to the other poems," though it can also be interpreted as "a crisis lived through and overcome than a crisis presently experienced in the act of writing." With this source, I am able to relate to other sonnets that Donne has written and make a comparison between them to establish a deeper analysis of the sonnet.
Fenner, Arthur. "Donne's 'Holy Sonnet XII'." Explicator 40.4 (1982): 14-15. MLA International Bibliography. EBSCO. Web. 3 Mar. 2010.
In this article, Arthur Fenner directly analyzes the use of language in Donne's Holy Sonnet XII. Through his use of both text and visual comparisons, it is clear that the author has intended this article for literary researchers as well as students who are specifically studying Donne's Holy Sonnet XII. Being an article reviewed by other literary scholars and consistently containing references to the text, this is certainly a credible source. I can take into account the arguments this author has made about Holy Sonnet XII to refine my own arguments about the sonnet. This source is particularly useful because it conveys its ideas partly through a "mathematical diagram" that compares how Donne establishes the fact that nature and animals that are pure and sinless are greater than men who are weak and sinful who are yet in the end still greater than nature and animals. I can also employ this strategy of including a visual similar to the mathematical diagram to better convey my argument.
Kuchar, Gary. "Petrarchism and Repentance in John Donne's Holy Sonnets." Modern Philology: Critical and Historical Studies in Literature, Medieval Through Contemporary 105.3 (2008): 535-569. MLA International Bibliography. EBSCO. Web. 3 Mar. 2010.
In this article, Gary Kuchar assesses the motif of repentenance and references to God in Donne's Holy Sonnets. As a writer of critical and historical studies in English literature, Kuchar writes to a more sophisticated and scholarly audience that is interested in deeply analyzing patterns found in Donne's poetry. This is certainly a credible source, as it is a peer reviewed journal article, and multiple citations to the text are used to support the overarching argument. This source will serve to familiarize me with Donne's writing style and the distinguishing patterns and relationships among Donne's sonnets. Unlike the other sources, this is a more general analysis of Donne's Holy Sonnets as a whole, rather than an analysis of a specific poem, which will serve to give me some background information to draw upon when I am making my own claims about Donne's Holy Sonnet XII.
Renaker, David. "Do Donne's Holy Sonnets Tell a Story?" The Atheist Seventeenth Century Website. N.p., 2002-2004. Web. 3 Mar. 2010. .
In this essay, David Renaker assesses all seventeen of Donne's Holy Sonnets. The author is a professor writing to provide an analysis on Donne's Holy Sonnets to a general educated audience including college students and other professors. This source is credible, since the author is a professor of English literature and there is an elaborate section where he cites his sources as well. Renaker provides a brief analysis on each sonnet, which I can use as a starting point for my own analysis. The information he provides is neither too vague nor too specific and adequately provdies an overview of Donne's purpose in writing Holy Sonnet XII.
Description of Format:
I will most likely print out a separate copy of the sonnet and annotate on top of there. I am also thinking about breaking up the sonnet physically to emphasize the effects of the particular structure of the sonnet.
10 Annotations:
Beaston - sonnets are interconnected, "the reader cannot expect to find a satisfying conclusion to any single sonnet," so what role does sonnet XII play in the series of sonnets?
Beaston - "these poems are not meant to portray the entire spiritual journey of the speaker"
Bellette - "Without that sense of crisis and disorder which is central to the other poems," "a crisis lived through and overcome than a crisis presently experienced in the act of writing."
Bellette - "There is an 'audience' as present as in the secular poems. It might consist of listening Soul, it might even be bull, boar, and ignorant horse, as in XII, but the effect is constant: the speaker can answer, demonstrate and resolve as he could not when lacking both audience and authority."
Fenner - "a sonnet by Donne that achieves its power entirely by a structure of explicit argument. It has no imagery, absolutely no metaphors, scarcely anything that can be called figurative"
Fenner - elements, pure, animals, strong, sinless > man, weak, sinner > yet man > elements animals
Fenner - paradox: God > created nature > elements and animals > man > God
Fenner - "foes raises a paradox to a still higher power...in this relationship, hate is confronted with love"
Kuchar - reference to God, pattern among holy sonnets, talks about sin and repentenance
Renaker - "The envy of animals for having no souls to be damned now becomes conescension and pity at their inability to appreciate the Incarnation."
Thursday, March 4, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Ahh, Jeremy, you are so good at this! Your annotations are clear and get your point across. You seem to have a really good idea of what you want to do with this assignment and are well on your way.
ReplyDeleteThe breaking up the sonnet and annotating that way is a really good idea that I would not have thought of. Keep it up!